Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
lynnrbkh

To Grain or Not to Grain.... That is the Question

42 posts in this topic

* Let me know if this should be on the debate forum *

Another topic had me thinking... When is it necessary to grain a horse?

When the horse is fed sufficent hay and supplements to maintain his weight, and is being worked several days a week, he does not need grain. I think grain should *only* be brought into the feeding program when the horse can no longer maintain a healthy weight level or energy level.

What say you?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

* Let me know if this should be on the debate forum *

Another topic had me thinking... When is it necessary to grain a horse?

When the horse is fed sufficent hay and supplements to maintain his weight, and is being worked several days a week, he does not need grain. I think grain should *only* be brought into the feeding program when the horse can no longer maintain a healthy weight level or energy level.

What say you?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The majority of a horse's diet should be forage. If you cannot supply enough calories or nutrients through forage, then the addition of supplements and/or grains might be needed.

Most stock breeds, ponies, and drafts in anything less than heavy work or lactating do not need grain.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The majority of a horse's diet should be forage. If you cannot supply enough calories or nutrients through forage, then the addition of supplements and/or grains might be needed.

Most stock breeds, ponies, and drafts in anything less than heavy work or lactating do not need grain.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Basically i agree. Each horse must be taken as an individual though, and one must look at the whole diet.

I do grain weanlings and yearlings, but only make it a small part of their diet,

I also have a show mare that is an easy keeper and insulin resistent. She never gets grain, even when worked very regularily during show season. She looks great on good timothy hay and some soaked beet pulp, plus free choice saltand minerals

Other horses get grain only as a treat, when they are ridden, making being caught a good thing.

I bring them into the barn and give them a very small scoop of whole oats just as a treat, before saddling up

So yes, for mature horses not in heavy training and just ridden recreationally , maintaining their weight on good hay and having access to minerals and salt, no grain is needed.

This is the healthiest and most natural diet for horses. Just as many horses if not more, are over fed these days, as compared to starved. Neither is good. All kinds of health problems go hand in hand with over feeding, esp carbohydrates.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Basically i agree. Each horse must be taken as an individual though, and one must look at the whole diet.

I do grain weanlings and yearlings, but only make it a small part of their diet,

I also have a show mare that is an easy keeper and insulin resistent. She never gets grain, even when worked very regularily during show season. She looks great on good timothy hay and some soaked beet pulp, plus free choice saltand minerals

Other horses get grain only as a treat, when they are ridden, making being caught a good thing.

I bring them into the barn and give them a very small scoop of whole oats just as a treat, before saddling up

So yes, for mature horses not in heavy training and just ridden recreationally , maintaining their weight on good hay and having access to minerals and salt, no grain is needed.

This is the healthiest and most natural diet for horses. Just as many horses if not more, are over fed these days, as compared to starved. Neither is good. All kinds of health problems go hand in hand with over feeding, esp carbohydrates.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with all of the above, a horses digestive system was designed to digest large amounts of roughage. I do like graining young horses a little bit to gentle them, and as a treat for catching a stubborn horse, but none of ours are grained frequently. If their condition is good and they have free choice salt and mineral than hay and or grazing is all they need in my opinion. [big Grin]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with all of the above, a horses digestive system was designed to digest large amounts of roughage. I do like graining young horses a little bit to gentle them, and as a treat for catching a stubborn horse, but none of ours are grained frequently. If their condition is good and they have free choice salt and mineral than hay and or grazing is all they need in my opinion. [big Grin]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think every horse should get some grain, if only enough to add supplements to. My reasoning is this: Unless you own a thousand acres that your horses free roam on, they are not getting what they need from our hay and pasture grasses. Every area of the US has been overworked to the point of depleting the soil of the nutrients a horse needs. If you disagree with this, I suggest you start doing some reading on the subject.

I have a heavy draft and she gets enough grain to hold her oil and supplements.

My saddle horse gets grain to hold her weight. She gets enough quality hay but she would be too skinny otherwise. JMHO

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think every horse should get some grain, if only enough to add supplements to. My reasoning is this: Unless you own a thousand acres that your horses free roam on, they are not getting what they need from our hay and pasture grasses. Every area of the US has been overworked to the point of depleting the soil of the nutrients a horse needs. If you disagree with this, I suggest you start doing some reading on the subject.

I have a heavy draft and she gets enough grain to hold her oil and supplements.

My saddle horse gets grain to hold her weight. She gets enough quality hay but she would be too skinny otherwise. JMHO

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think its crazy how many horse people OVER feed. It's simply amazing to me that some people I know expect their horses to have food in front of them EVERY time they pass their horse's stall... no, I'm not even kidding. One woman I board with who feeds occasionally, tries to throw my horse a THIRD of a bale of hay A DAY. I ended up locking up my hay so she would stay out of it and stop feeding my horse.

Grain is GROSSLY overfed, IMO.

Many horses don't even need it, they get it because their owners want them to have it. My horse gets TWO HANDFULLS of grain a day. That's all he needs to supplement the extra calories he burns during his workouts, since he's a VERY easy keeper. But Im shocked how much grain people feed their horses. Now I can see racehorses that are hard keepers needing 8 quarts a day, but when i see people giving their fat, pasture-kept, never-ridden horses a full scoop twice a day its just stupid.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think its crazy how many horse people OVER feed. It's simply amazing to me that some people I know expect their horses to have food in front of them EVERY time they pass their horse's stall... no, I'm not even kidding. One woman I board with who feeds occasionally, tries to throw my horse a THIRD of a bale of hay A DAY. I ended up locking up my hay so she would stay out of it and stop feeding my horse.

Grain is GROSSLY overfed, IMO.

Many horses don't even need it, they get it because their owners want them to have it. My horse gets TWO HANDFULLS of grain a day. That's all he needs to supplement the extra calories he burns during his workouts, since he's a VERY easy keeper. But Im shocked how much grain people feed their horses. Now I can see racehorses that are hard keepers needing 8 quarts a day, but when i see people giving their fat, pasture-kept, never-ridden horses a full scoop twice a day its just stupid.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

quote:

Originally posted by lynnrbkh:

* Let me know if this should be on the debate forum *

Another topic had me thinking... When is it necessary to grain a horse?

When the horse is fed sufficent hay and supplements to maintain his weight, and is being worked several days a week, he does not need grain. I think grain should *only* be brought into the feeding program when the horse can no longer maintain a healthy weight level or energy level.

What say you?

you have a pm [smile]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

quote:

Originally posted by lynnrbkh:

* Let me know if this should be on the debate forum *

Another topic had me thinking... When is it necessary to grain a horse?

When the horse is fed sufficent hay and supplements to maintain his weight, and is being worked several days a week, he does not need grain. I think grain should *only* be brought into the feeding program when the horse can no longer maintain a healthy weight level or energy level.

What say you?

you have a pm [smile]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't grain anything I own currently. I have free supplements available to them and they are on pasture all summer and hay as needed in the winter. Even when in heavy work-6 days a week-they don't get or need IMHO grain. Also, most are OTTBs, you know the "hard keepers" who currently look about ready to foal going in to winter. I would never say never, but almost never for my herd.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't grain anything I own currently. I have free supplements available to them and they are on pasture all summer and hay as needed in the winter. Even when in heavy work-6 days a week-they don't get or need IMHO grain. Also, most are OTTBs, you know the "hard keepers" who currently look about ready to foal going in to winter. I would never say never, but almost never for my herd.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

quote:

Originally posted by SunshineAcres:

I think every horse should get some grain, if only enough to add supplements to. My reasoning is this: Unless you own a thousand acres that your horses free roam on, they are not getting what they need from our hay and pasture grasses. Every area of the US has been overworked to the point of depleting the soil of the nutrients a horse needs. If you disagree with this, I suggest you start doing some reading on the subject.

I have a heavy draft and she gets enough grain to hold her oil and supplements.

My saddle horse gets grain to hold her weight. She gets enough quality hay but she would be too skinny otherwise. JMHO

Even if you rotate pastures and ensure that none of them are overgrazed? Buddy has said several times that soil should be analyzed and horses should be supplemented for whatever's lacking in the soil, but that can be done without grain. I think.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

quote:

Originally posted by SunshineAcres:

I think every horse should get some grain, if only enough to add supplements to. My reasoning is this: Unless you own a thousand acres that your horses free roam on, they are not getting what they need from our hay and pasture grasses. Every area of the US has been overworked to the point of depleting the soil of the nutrients a horse needs. If you disagree with this, I suggest you start doing some reading on the subject.

I have a heavy draft and she gets enough grain to hold her oil and supplements.

My saddle horse gets grain to hold her weight. She gets enough quality hay but she would be too skinny otherwise. JMHO

Even if you rotate pastures and ensure that none of them are overgrazed? Buddy has said several times that soil should be analyzed and horses should be supplemented for whatever's lacking in the soil, but that can be done without grain. I think.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a warmblood heavy on the draft side, I would love not to grain her. Unfortunately to get her supplements down for her joint issues I give her 1/2 to 3/4 a scoop of grain 2X a day. Technically it is reccommended to feed her a 1/4 a scoop 2X a day. I am on agreement on less grain the better unless you have a hard keeper.

IMO,

Kathy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a warmblood heavy on the draft side, I would love not to grain her. Unfortunately to get her supplements down for her joint issues I give her 1/2 to 3/4 a scoop of grain 2X a day. Technically it is reccommended to feed her a 1/4 a scoop 2X a day. I am on agreement on less grain the better unless you have a hard keeper.

IMO,

Kathy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mine just get a handful of grain that there supplements are mixed in with.

We used to grain all the time, but I don't anymore. Not unless they are really being ridden hard, but the hay that they receive is tested and they all do really well.

Cols

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you test your forage (be it hay or pasture or both) and supplement for deficiencies, horses should be able to get all their nutritional needs met through forage.

Now, I said nutritional...not caloric. Some horses DO need more calories to maintain a healthy weight.

But not all horses NEED grain. They really don't.

In fact, some horses really shouldn't have any at all. My mare is IR. She does not get grain. She gets "an oat" or a handful of beet pulp to mix her selenium supplement with which equates to literally 30 grains of oats or 10 pellets of BP. That's it.

I have to limit her caloric intake or she can have a plethora of other issues....

And this talk about low cal feeds? It's silliness to me. If the horse needs less calories, stop feeding it GRAIN!!!

Feeding horses isn't magic...and there's no "one size fits all"....each horse is an individual and their needs should be addressed as such. But, generally speaking, if you test your forage and supp for deficiencies, most horses do very well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mine just get a handful of grain that there supplements are mixed in with.

We used to grain all the time, but I don't anymore. Not unless they are really being ridden hard, but the hay that they receive is tested and they all do really well.

Cols

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you test your forage (be it hay or pasture or both) and supplement for deficiencies, horses should be able to get all their nutritional needs met through forage.

Now, I said nutritional...not caloric. Some horses DO need more calories to maintain a healthy weight.

But not all horses NEED grain. They really don't.

In fact, some horses really shouldn't have any at all. My mare is IR. She does not get grain. She gets "an oat" or a handful of beet pulp to mix her selenium supplement with which equates to literally 30 grains of oats or 10 pellets of BP. That's it.

I have to limit her caloric intake or she can have a plethora of other issues....

And this talk about low cal feeds? It's silliness to me. If the horse needs less calories, stop feeding it GRAIN!!!

Feeding horses isn't magic...and there's no "one size fits all"....each horse is an individual and their needs should be addressed as such. But, generally speaking, if you test your forage and supp for deficiencies, most horses do very well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My horse gets a handful of low-CARB grain each day, enough to put his hoof supplements in. He is on pasture 24/7, with free choice hay from now til about May, when the grass is in again. He is ridden lightly, but loses too much weight over the winter without extra calories.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My horse gets a handful of low-CARB grain each day, enough to put his hoof supplements in. He is on pasture 24/7, with free choice hay from now til about May, when the grass is in again. He is ridden lightly, but loses too much weight over the winter without extra calories.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

quote:

My reasoning is this: Unless you own a thousand acres that your horses free roam on, they are not getting what they need from our hay and pasture grasses. Every area of the US has been overworked to the point of depleting the soil of the nutrients a horse needs.

Actually most hay is MORE nutritious and higher in protein than the natural grasses that horses have 'historically' grazed on.

Our hay areas ( levees and hill ground) are seeded to grow specific types of highly nutritious and dense grasses.

I quit feeding grain a year ago and switched to a ration balancer with a couple of suppliments to cover what our grass hay is missing.

Very few horses need grain.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

quote:

My reasoning is this: Unless you own a thousand acres that your horses free roam on, they are not getting what they need from our hay and pasture grasses. Every area of the US has been overworked to the point of depleting the soil of the nutrients a horse needs.

Actually most hay is MORE nutritious and higher in protein than the natural grasses that horses have 'historically' grazed on.

Our hay areas ( levees and hill ground) are seeded to grow specific types of highly nutritious and dense grasses.

I quit feeding grain a year ago and switched to a ration balancer with a couple of suppliments to cover what our grass hay is missing.

Very few horses need grain.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0